Skip to main content
Book a Strategy Session
left arrow in circle outlineBack To Home

Marketing for Not-for-Profits: The 60% Nobody Writes For

sagar sethi
Sagar Sethi
October 17, 2026

Most of the marketing advice written for charities is written for an organisation that does not exist for most of the people reading it. It assumes a marketing manager, a budget line and a dashboard. The reader is more often one part-time coordinator, a volunteer committee and a few thousand dollars.

Table of Contents

I have spent thirteen years doing this work for Australian organisations, and the pattern in small charities is consistent. Money gets spent in March on something nobody can measure by July, and then the annual reporting obligation asks what it produced.

What follows is how I would rebuild the whole thing around the constraint that actually binds: unpaid hours. The shape of the sector and why the funded end gets all the advice. A budget measured in volunteer hours rather than dollars. The one question a funder is really asking. The four assets worth building in the first year. The channels that respect volunteer time. A worked example a committee can run in a single meeting. And the measurement that survives a volunteer roster.

One boundary before we start. This is not fundraising strategy, not grant writing, and not a governance or compliance opinion. It is not a promise that any of it will raise donations or win funding. It is marketing for a not-for-profit that has to be findable and understood by people who are not yet in the conversation with you.

The smallest useful action is at the end: three numbers, one spreadsheet, twenty minutes a month. If you do one thing after reading this, do that one.

The Australian Charity Sector Is Two Markets, Not One

What the ACNC's own data shows about where the money sits

Start with the register itself, because the figures below describe the whole Australian charity sector rather than a survey sample. The Australian Charities and Not-for-profits Commission's Australian Charities Report, 12th edition, states: "We present findings based on information from 53,641 Annual Information Statements submitted by charities for the 2024 reporting period."

Inside that register the split is severe. The report says of the extra large charities, those with annual revenue of $100 million or more and 0.6% of the sector: "Yet they generated 57% of total sector revenue, received around 21% of donations and bequests, and held roughly half of all sector assets." The next sentence, from the same page and therefore the same data set, is the one this post is named for: "By comparison, 60% of all charities were small or extra small (less than $500,000 in annual revenue)."

Those small and extra small charities together generate 1.4% of sector revenue and hold under 5% of sector assets, both stated on the same page. So the comparison is not between well run charities and badly run ones. It is between two completely different operating environments that share one register and one set of sector headlines.

Why search results are written for the funded end

Now the sector totals, because they explain the pressure you are under. Same report: "Charities generated $239 billion in revenue, a significant 7.5% increase that surpassed growth in the wider economy." And in the next paragraph: "However, total sector expenses rose by 8.6%, to $231 billion, outpacing this revenue growth."

Sector growth is not your growth, and the margin between those two figures is exactly why a small organisation is being asked to do more with the same money rather than less. The growth sits with the organisations that already have the revenue, the systems and the marketing staff.

The not for profit marketing advice you can find follows the money too. The guides, the case studies, the conference sessions and the award entries come from organisations that can pay for them, which is why so much charity marketing writing assumes a team. When you search for help, you are mostly reading what the funded end wrote about itself.

The three constraints a volunteer-run charity actually has

Unpaid hours are the main resource, and they arrive in four hour blocks on weekday evenings. There is an annual reporting obligation that will ask what the activity produced. And there is rarely a shared definition of success, so a committee burns a meeting debating channels when the real disagreement is about what the organisation is for this year.

Every section below is built around those three, in that order. Money is the fourth constraint, and for most organisations reading this it is the smallest of the four.

Your Marketing Budget Is Mostly Hours

"It is remarkable that more than half of all charities, 53%, operated with no paid staff, relying entirely on the dedication of their volunteers." That is the same ACNC report, and it should reframe the whole exercise. If most of the sector runs on volunteers, then a not for profit marketing budget written in dollars describes a small part of what actually happens. The report also records 3.9 million volunteers engaged by registered charities, the highest count ever reported to the ACNC, so the hours are there. They are simply not counted as a budget.

Counting the volunteer hours you already have

Write the hours down before you write down a single dollar. Take the committee and the active volunteer list, ask each person how many hours a month they give the organisation, and split those hours by what they are spent on. Most organisations discover that between thirty and sixty hours a month are going into work that produces no record of who it reached: printing, chasing photos, reformatting a document somebody else already laid out, rebuilding a spreadsheet that was fine in January.

The point of the count is not to make anyone feel bad about their contribution. It is to find out what you are already spending, because a resource you cannot see is a resource you cannot move.

What hours can do that money cannot

Volunteers hold the thing an outside supplier cannot buy: they know what people ask when they walk in, what makes someone hesitate at the door, and which referral a family actually trusts. That knowledge is the raw material for every asset in section 4. Someone outside can format and publish it. Nobody outside can supply it.

Hours also buy trust in a way money does not, particularly in a small community where a familiar face is often the reason somebody picks up the phone at all.

What to keep cash for, and what to stop buying

Keep cash for the work volunteers genuinely cannot do: a small amount of production that has to be finished by a date, and any specialist advice you cannot get from a peer organisation. Stop buying the things that create an ongoing obligation you have no capacity to maintain, because an asset you cannot keep current stops being an asset.

I will not hand you a percentage of budget rule. Every benchmark of that kind assumes a staffing model you do not have, which is why I do not use them. If you want the arithmetic done with your own numbers, work the arithmetic with your own figures before the committee meeting rather than adopting someone else's ratio.

Start With the One Question Funders Ask

What an Annual Information Statement and an acquittal want to see

The question underneath every reporting obligation is the same one. What did the money do, who did it reach, and how do you know. An organisation that answers that question in numbers has a materially easier conversation than one that lists activities.

Two things to be clear about. Nothing here is financial, tax or compliance advice, and your reporting obligations belong with your board and your accountant rather than with a marketing page. And the evidence is far easier to gather as you go than to reconstruct once the reporting period has closed.

Turning activity into evidence as you go

Ask one question at intake, and ask it every time: how did you hear about us. Whether the answer arrives by phone, through a form or in person, it takes a few seconds and it becomes the only reliable link between what you published and who turned up. Without it, you end the year holding a list of activities and no way to say which one worked.

Record the answer in the same place every time, even when that place is a shared spreadsheet. A referral source written down in March is worth more in July than anyone's memory of it.

The three numbers to write down from day one

First, how many people contacted you for the thing you do this month. Enquiries, referrals or applications rather than page views. Second, how many of those became the outcome you wanted, whether that outcome is a participant, a volunteer, a donor or a partner. Third, which activity produced them.

Those three columns are the whole measurement system for a volunteer-run organisation, and section 8 is about how to read them.

The Four Assets Worth Building in Year One

Four assets, built once and maintained lightly. Not a channel strategy and not a campaign calendar. If the organisation can only finish one of them this year, finish the first, because the other three need somewhere to send people.

A page that explains what you do, who for and where

One page, plain language, answering the questions people ask on the phone: what you do, who is eligible, where you operate, what happens after somebody makes contact, and whether it costs them anything. Most charity websites answer the first question and skip the rest, which is why the phone rings all day with questions the page could have answered.

If the problem is that people cannot find or understand what you do, that is the content side, and it is worth treating as one piece of work rather than an ongoing habit.

A way to give that works on a phone

Test your own donation process on a phone, in under a minute, as somebody who has never seen the site. If it takes more than three steps, or asks for information a donor would have to go and find, the gift is lost. This is a mechanism rather than a campaign: one clear button, one working payment page, one automatic receipt.

One email list you own

Every channel you do not own can change its rules, its reach or its price without asking you. Build one list of people who have said they want to hear from you and keep it somewhere you control. What you send matters less than the fact that you can send it at all. Small organisations consistently overestimate what social media reach is worth compared with a list of two hundred people who actually read your email.

One measurable intake or referral path

Choose one way for people to reach you and measure that one: a phone number, a short form, or a referral from a partner organisation with a named contact. One measured path beats four unmeasured ones, and it is the piece that makes the three numbers in section 3 possible at all.

Channels That Respect Volunteer Time

Local search and the map pack

The modest size of this sector works in your favour. In Australia, "not for profit marketing" carries around 210 searches a month, "charity seo" around 50 and "marketing for charities" around 20 (Semrush, database au, October 2026). Those are not numbers that justify a retainer, and they are exactly the numbers one volunteer can compete for. Claim the free listing for your location, keep the address, phone number and opening hours identical to what is on your own site, and describe what you do in the words your community uses rather than the words in your constitution.

Partner, referral and member organisations

The fastest route to the people you serve is usually another organisation that already sees them: a council service, a school, a clinic, a sporting club, a member body. Build one page for referrers that tells them exactly who you can take, what you need from them and how quickly you respond. Then send those partners a short update each quarter, in the same format every time, so the relationship does not depend on one person remembering it.

Social media as a support act, not the plan

Post the things you already produce: photographs from the work, a note when a program opens, thanks to a volunteer who has done twenty years. Do not build a content calendar you cannot sustain in your busiest month. A channel you post on twice a week for most of the year beats one you abandon in November, and the abandonment is what does the damage.

The Worked Example: Forty Volunteers and Six Thousand Dollars

Here is the exercise I would run with a committee in a single meeting. The figures are an illustration and the method is the point, so replace them with yours.

Mapping the 160 hours you already spend

Forty active volunteers giving four hours a month is 160 hours a month of capacity. Most organisations have never seen that number written down, and even fewer have seen where it goes. Split it into three columns: service delivery, administration, and communication. In the organisations I have worked with, the communication column is the one nobody has ever audited, and it usually holds hours spent producing things with no record of who read them.

Deciding what the 50 spare hours buy

Suppose the audit frees fifty hours a month out of work that produces no record. Fifty hours is more marketing capacity than most small charities have ever had, and it is already paid for. Decide in the meeting what those hours buy for the next quarter: the four assets, or one of them done properly, or the quarterly updates to referrers. Write the decision down with a name beside it, or the hours will be reabsorbed by the next thing that needs printing.

What the $6,000 should pay for

Cash should buy three things at this size: production that has to be finished to a date, one specialist task nobody on the committee can do, and nothing else.

What it should not buy is a rebrand, a subscription nobody owns, or a campaign that needs feeding every week. Before the committee commits, a review of what you are already doing, before you add anything to it, is usually the better first spend, because it stops the second one being wasted.

The line you write in the acquittal

A sentence in the same three-number format all year: we spent $6,000 and received 41 enquiries, of which 19 became participants, and here is where they came from. Those figures are the worked example rather than a target. The structure is what matters, and it is the difference between describing activity and answering the question.

If your board has started asking what the marketing spend returned and nobody can answer, that question is the first one worth fixing. And where the organisation is large enough for paid staff to do the work, this is what it looks like for an organisation with a small in-house team.

What Not to Do With a Small Charity Budget

Do not buy a rebrand you cannot maintain

A new identity arrives with templates, rules and a set of files somebody has to apply consistently for years. In a volunteer-run organisation, that consistency is the first thing to go when the person who championed the project moves on, and you are left paying for a look that no longer appears anywhere. Fix the page that explains what you do first.

Do not run ads you cannot answer the phone for

Paid search can work for a small charity when people are already searching for the exact thing you offer and somebody can respond to an enquiry within a day. If the page does not explain what you do, or the phone rings through to an unattended line, the money buys you a missed call. Cap it, run it in the two months that matter most to you, and treat it as a test of the page rather than as a growth engine.

Do not chase a viral moment in your peak month

Your peak month is when the demand you already have arrives. Diverting the committee into a campaign that might travel is how an intake list goes unanswered in the one month it mattered. Post the things you already produce, and put the effort into the enquiries in front of you.

If the pattern above describes your last twelve months, the issue is not a missing channel. It is a plan built around the hours and dollars an organisation actually has, and it fits on one page.

Measuring It Without a Dashboard

Three numbers to check each month

How many people found you for the thing you do, which for most charities means enquiries, referrals or applications rather than page views. How many of those became the outcome you wanted. And which activity produced them, which you can only answer if the intake question is asked every time. That is a spreadsheet with three columns rather than a platform, and one person can keep it current in twenty minutes a month.

If you cannot answer the third question at all, fix that before you spend anything else, because without it every future decision is a guess with a budget attached to it.

What good looks like for a small charity

The honest answer is that flat is acceptable in the first quarter, as long as the third column is being filled in. The first number will be small, because the search demand in this sector is small. What you are watching over two quarters is the shape of the relationship between an activity and the enquiries that follow it.

When to change something and when to leave it alone

Change a channel when the third column shows it has produced nothing for two quarters while another has produced most of your intake. Leave it alone when the numbers are thin but the direction is right, because a volunteer-run organisation that changes channels every month measures nothing except its own restlessness. When a change is genuinely needed, make one at a time so you can still see what moved.

Frequently asked questions

We have volunteers, not a marketing budget. Where do we start?

Start by writing down the hours you already have, not the money you do not. A committee of forty people giving four hours a month is 160 hours, which is a real marketing budget and it is already being spent somewhere. Map where those hours actually go for one month, honestly, including the ones lost to printing, chasing photos and formatting a newsletter nobody asked for. Most small charities have between thirty and sixty hours a month going into work that produces no record of who it reached. Move those first. Money comes second, and only for the two or three things volunteers genuinely cannot do.

Can a charity spend money on marketing and still satisfy its funders?

Yes, and the funders who matter will ask you to. What gets a charity into trouble is not spending on marketing, it is being unable to say what the spend produced. So treat every marketing dollar the way you treat program money: decide before you spend it what number will tell you it worked, write that number down, and record the result even when the result is disappointing. An acquittal that says "we spent $6,000 and received 41 enquiries, of which 19 became participants, and here is where they came from" is stronger than one that lists activity without outcomes. Nothing here is financial or compliance advice, and your own reporting obligations are for your board and your accountant.

Should we run Google Ads?

Sometimes, and much less than you think. Paid search is worth it for a small charity when three things are true at once: people are actively searching the exact term you want to be found for, the thing you are offering can absorb the enquiries, and someone will answer within a day. It is a waste when the landing page does not explain what you do, which is the most common fault I see on charity sites. Cap it, run it in the two months that matter to you, and treat it as a test of your page rather than as a growth engine. If it does not work in eight weeks, the page is usually the problem, not the bid.

What is the difference between marketing and fundraising?

Fundraising asks a specific person for a specific gift towards a specific thing. Marketing makes your organisation findable, understandable and trustworthy to people who are not yet in that conversation, whether they eventually give, refer, volunteer or use your service. The confusion costs small charities money: they buy fundraising campaigns when the real problem is that nobody searching for what they do can find them or work out whether they qualify. Both matter, they use different budget, and they are measured differently. If your only marketing activity is an appeal, you are renting attention once a year instead of owning any.

How do we measure marketing when we are volunteer run?

With three numbers and no dashboard. First, how many people found you for the thing you do this month, which for most charities means enquiries, referrals or applications, not page views. Second, how many of those became the outcome you wanted, whether that is a participant, a donation, a volunteer or a partner. Third, which of your activities produced them, which you can only answer if you ask one question at intake. That is a spreadsheet, not a platform, and one person can maintain it in twenty minutes a month. If you cannot answer the third question at all, fix that before you spend anything else.

We are a national charity with a small in-house team. Does any of this apply?

Partly. If you have paid staff, your constraint is likely time and internal approval rather than unpaid labour, and the parts above about mapping volunteer hours will not fit you. The parts that will fit are the funder evidence point and the argument that your sector-level growth is not your growth. Where you have a marketing function, the harder question is usually not what to do but what to stop doing, because a small team spread across six channels produces six mediocre results. Pick the two channels that reach your actual beneficiaries and put the rest on hold for two quarters.

What to Do This Month

Three actions, and none of them needs a budget. Write down the volunteer hours you have and split them by what they are spent on. Add the intake question to every conversation and start the three-column spreadsheet. Then open the page that explains what you do and check whether it answers the questions your community actually asks.

If the honest answer is that nobody searching for what you do can find you or work out whether they qualify, the fix is small and unglamorous, and tell me what your last twelve months of marketing cost and I will tell you what I would keep is where that conversation starts.

The line worth remembering: you have already paid for most of your marketing capacity in hours. The work is deciding what those hours are for.

Are you doing SEO or Ads?

Get a free consultation with us

Stop wasting money on ads that are not working.

Get advertising that is intentional and measured properly.

  • Bring me your current spend, your volunteer hours and the last twelve months of enquiries, and I will tell you what I would keep, what I would cut and what I would do next.
  • You get a short list of what to stop rather than a campaign proposal, and if the honest answer is that you should not spend anything yet, I will say so.
free digital marketing consultation

Get in touch with us!

Contact UsContact UsDigital marketing logo light variant
scale your business with sagar sethi

Looking to scale your business?

I offer digital marketing consulting, web design and development services.
Learn MoreDigital marketing logo light variant
Sagar Sethi

About Sagar Sethi

I came to Australia in 2006 with $500 to my name and a dream to make it big. No job was big or small as long as I stuck to my values and it got closer to my goals. Today I run a successful digital marketing agency. 


It has always operated with a 'Human First' approach. Our values keep us square and keep the fluff out. We have worked with some of the biggest names in Australian business. 

Latest Blog

View All Blogs

Awards & Certifications

Xugar's curved branding element, representing innovative marketing consulting

WINNER

Web Excellence
Awards
2024
Xugar's curved branding element, representing innovative marketing consulting

FINALIST

Australian Small Business Champion Awards
2024
Xugar's curved branding element, representing innovative marketing consulting

FINALIST

Business xCellence Awards
2024
Xugar's curved branding element, representing innovative marketing consulting

WINNER

Local Business
Awards
2024

Book a free 30-minute Strategy Session

Tell me a bit about your business and we can dial in a strategy that fits.

    sagar sethi
    linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram

    Xugar Holiday Offer