Skip to main content
Book a Strategy Session
left arrow in circle outlineBack To Home

Insurance Broker Marketing: The Gap Between Renewals

sagar sethi
Sagar Sethi
October 17, 2026

Every broker I speak to describes the same problem, and almost all of them describe it wrongly. They say they need more leads. The data says the clients are still there and the share of them has gone.

Table of Contents

An SME that has been with the same brokerage for nine years can quietly place two of its four covers somewhere else, and nobody at the brokerage finds out until the client leaves entirely. Thirteen years of this work has taught me that the problem is rarely at the front of the funnel. It sits in the eleven months between renewals, when nobody is talking to the client about anything.

What follows is how I would market a brokerage against that reality. What the market data shows about how SMEs now buy. The questions an owner actually types after a claim or a near miss. The three pages a brokerage genuinely needs. How renewal conversations become content. A worked example a principal can run in one sitting. And the two numbers worth checking every quarter.

One boundary before we start. This is general information about marketing, not personal advice on insurance, not a compliance opinion, and not a promise of new business. Anything about a specific policy, a named insurer or a client's own cover belongs in a conversation between the broker and the client, not in a marketing page.

The smallest useful action is in section 8, and it takes an hour.

The Problem Is Not Leads, It Is the Gap Between Renewals

What the market data shows about how SMEs now buy insurance

Start with where the buyers went, because it is the spine of everything below. The 2025 Vero SME Insurance Index, reported by Insurance Business Australia, found that "In 2018, over a quarter of SMEs used brokers for most of their insurance needs, but by 2025, that figure had dropped to 10%." The same article: "Instead, 74% of businesses now use a mix of direct purchases and broker services." That research surveyed 1,750 Australian businesses, and it is sponsored insurer research rather than a government or regulator figure, which is worth knowing when you weigh it.

Read those two sentences together and the practical meaning is precise. The typical SME has not left. It has spread. Some covers stay with you because the relationship and the advice are worth something, and others move to a direct purchase because the price is visible and the decision feels small at the time.

The channel itself is not shrinking, which rules out the comfortable explanation. NIBA's sector report, Data to Direction, which is an industry body report drawing on APRA data, states that "Brokers are managing AU$35.6 billion in intermediated gross written premiums", and that broking represents "nearly half (46%) of all general insurance written in Australia." That is a large, functioning market. It is not losing to direct insurers overall. Individual brokerages are losing share inside their own client books, and that is a different problem with a different fix. It is also why insurance broker marketing is mostly a retention exercise rather than an acquisition one.

Why year one is fine and year two is not

The first year of a relationship is a project. You review the covers, you explain what changed, and you are in contact because there is work to do. By year two the covers are set, the renewal arrives as an email, and the only contact in twelve months is a renewal notice. That is the point at which a client becomes a name in a system, and the point at which a cheaper direct quote starts to look reasonable to somebody who has not heard from you since last year.

The marketing problem in a brokerage is therefore not acquisition. It is presence in the quiet period, and the number it moves is share of wallet rather than new logos.

The competitor you are actually losing to, which is inertia

The business that takes the cover is not always a competitor you can name. It is the path of least resistance: a renewal email answered with a signature, an online quote, a broker at another firm down the road, or a decision to look at it properly next year. Inertia is the competitor, and inertia is beaten by being the organisation that is still useful in the months when nothing is due.

What an SME Owner Searches When Something Goes Wrong

The questions that arrive after a claim or a near miss

Most of the demand that matters arrives at a moment rather than steadily. Something happens, and the owner types a question: what does business interruption actually pay for, is a subcontractor covered, does the policy still work while the shop is closed for a fit-out, why did this renewal jump. Whoever answers that question first is in the conversation, and the rest find out later.

Underinsurance is the clearest evidence of why those moments matter. The same Vero index reports: "Underinsurance remains a persistent issue, as only 42% of businesses review their sum insured annually." It adds: "This figure rises to 63% among businesses that work closely with brokers, compared to 48% for those that do not engage brokers in insurance decisions." That is an association and not a cause. The index shows that businesses with a close broker relationship review their cover more often. It does not show that the relationship produces the review, and I would not claim it does.

Why the phrase "we are a broker" ranks for nothing

Nobody searches for a category description. They search with the risk in their own words, and those words are specific: what happens if a subbie is injured on site, whether stock is covered while the fit-out runs, what a claim looks like when the power is out for two days. A page that says the business offers insurance solutions for business is invisible to all of it, because it answers a question nobody asked.

This is the cheapest content advantage available to a brokerage, and it is not a volume game. In Australia, "seo for insurance brokers" carries around 110 searches a month and "insurance broker seo" around 20 (Semrush, database au, October 2026). The demand is small. The competition for it is thinner still, and the questions your own clients ask every week are worth more than any keyword list.

Where general information ends and personal advice begins

There is a line, and it is worth drawing before anyone writes anything. Explaining how a type of cover generally works, what a common clause is doing, or which questions to bring to a renewal is general information. Telling a specific business what to do about its own policy is personal advice, and that belongs in a conversation between the client and their broker. Everything in the next two sections sits on the general side of that line, and nothing about a named insurer, a product or a commission structure belongs in your content at all.

The Three Pages a Brokerage Genuinely Needs

The page that answers the question you are asked every week

Take the question you answer on the phone most often this month and turn it into a page. If you spend your mornings explaining business interruption cover to café owners, that is a page. If most of your calls in a quarter are about what happens when a subcontractor is injured, that is a page. The test is simple. If you answer it for more than a minute, more than once a month, it should exist as something you can send people to rather than something you repeat.

The industry page for the sectors you actually know well

Not a page per industry in the phone book sense. The three or four sectors where you can talk about real risks and real claim patterns: what goes wrong, what it costs when it does, and what an owner should have in place before it happens. Thirty thin industry pages are the most common fault I see on brokerage websites, and they compete with each other for nothing.

If you cannot write the sector page with specifics, you do not know that sector well enough to sell into it. That is useful information too, and it is cheaper to learn it now than after the campaign.

The claims page almost nobody writes

This is the single greatest trust asset a broker has, and it is almost always absent. What a claim looks like from the client's side: who they call, what you do, what happens in the first 48 hours, what you need from them, and how long each stage usually takes. Nobody chooses a broker from that page alone. It is the page that answers the question every owner is silently asking, and it competes with nobody.

Turn Renewal Conversations Into Content

De-identified, aggregated, permissioned: the three rules

Three rules, and you can apply them in ten minutes a week. Aggregate rather than individualise, so you describe a pattern across many claims rather than one client's story. Remove every identifying detail, including location, industry combination, timing and policy size, because the combination of those is often enough to identify a business. And ask before you publish, in writing, even when you are certain the client would not mind.

The monthly question log that writes itself

Every question a client asks that takes more than a minute to answer goes into one document, with the date and nothing else. At the end of the month, count them. The most repeated question is your next page, and the third or fourth most repeated is the one after that. This is the step most brokerages skip, and it is the reason their content drifts into topics nobody ever asked about.

Who drafts it and how long it should take

The topic and the substance come from the person who answers the phone. A principal or an account manager who knows the risk writes the bones of it in twenty minutes. The shape, the editing and the publishing rhythm are what you hand to somebody else. Two hours a week across the team produces around twelve pages a year that are demonstrably about things your clients want to know. The expertise cannot be bought. The production can.

Where the pattern is strong and you want it set down as written evidence without naming a client, turning claim patterns into written evidence that names no client is the part worth handing out.

Being Found Locally Without Buying Every Ad

Search and the map pack for a brokerage

A brokerage serves a defined patch, and most local searches happen inside it. The work is less technical than it sounds: claim the listing for each office you actually operate from, keep the address, phone number and opening hours identical to what is on your own site, and say in plain language which suburbs and industries you serve. If nobody can find you for the questions your clients already ask, the search side is a defined piece of work rather than an open-ended retainer.

Referral and professional partner pages that do real work

Broking sits inside a network: accountants, lawyers, property managers, bookkeepers, equipment financiers. They refer to you, and they need to know exactly what you are best at before they can do it with confidence. One page per partner type, telling them who you are right for, what you need from a referral and how quickly you respond, does more than any campaign aimed at them.

If that is a channel you fund with hours rather than dollars, how one channel sits inside the plan for the year is the way to decide whether it earns the time.

What paid search is for, and what it is not for

Paid search buys a moment, not a relationship. It is worth using where a specific high-intent question is being typed and you cannot own the answer any other way, and it is a waste on category terms nobody searches and on anything where the landing page does not explain what you do. If the honest problem is that too few conversations start at all, the enquiry system side is where to look before you buy clicks.

The Worked Example: Three Hundred Clients and One Extra Line

Here is the arithmetic I would run with a principal in one sitting. The figures are an illustration and the method is the point, so replace them with yours.

Your four numbers, in one sitting

Write down four things: how many clients you have, how many lines each client holds with you on average, what a line is worth to you over a year, and how many clients have held only one line for more than three years. Those four numbers describe the gap better than any report, and most principals have never seen them side by side on one page.

The arithmetic of recovering one extra line

Take 300 clients. Suppose a third of them hold a single line, and suppose you recover one additional line for a quarter of that group, which is 25 lines. Multiply that by what a line is worth to you and the number is usually large enough to matter and small enough to be believable. The same arithmetic applied to new-client acquisition rarely looks as good, because acquiring a client costs more than adding a line to one you already have.

The percentages here are an illustration, not a benchmark. What the exercise shows is that the largest number in the room is a retention and share figure rather than an acquisition one.

What that figure means for what you can spend

If recovering those lines is worth more than the equivalent new business, the content that supports those conversations has a budget you can defend, and it is measured against that figure rather than against clicks or traffic. It also means you do not need to invent a cost per lead for a channel you have not run yet. You already know what a line is worth to you.

Where those pieces need to sit in one plan for the year rather than beside it, that is how I work with brokers and other businesses that sell to other businesses.

Measuring the Gap, Not Just the Enquiry

Quotes issued, not clicks

The first number worth tracking is quotes issued, not website visits. A brokerage that issues ten more quotes a quarter from the same client base is doing something different from one with a busier website. Ask at first contact where the enquiry came from and what made them call, and write the answer down. That answer is the only thing that connects your pages to your pipeline.

Retention and lines per client

Lines per client is the metric that actually moves commission revenue in a brokerage, and retention tells you whether the relationship is holding. Both sit in your own system already, and neither of them depends on an analytics platform.

Two numbers to check each quarter

Lines per client, and the share of enquiries that arrive already understanding what you do. If lines per client is flat after two quarters of consistent publishing, the content is probably too general and needs to move closer to the questions in your own log. If it is rising, add the second page rather than the fifth channel.

The second number is also the honest reading of the underinsurance research. Businesses that work closely with a broker review their sum insured more often, at 63% against 48% for those that do not engage brokers in insurance decisions. The review and the relationship travel together in that data, and neither the index nor this post claims that one causes the other.

What to Fix First When Nobody Has Time

The first month

Start the question log and write one page: the question you answer most often, in the words your clients use. That is a month of work measured in hours rather than dollars, and it produces the first piece of content a client will actually read.

The first quarter

Add the industry page for the sector you know best, then the claims page. By the end of the quarter you have three pages that between them answer the questions arriving between renewals, and the log tells you which one to write next.

The work worth handing to someone outside

Editing, publishing rhythm and the measurement design are the parts worth paying for, because they are the parts that stop when the office gets busy. The expertise is not. NIBA's own site says of the association: "It serves as the collective voice of 380+ member firms and 14,000 individual brokers and authorised representatives." In a market that size nobody wins by outspending anyone. Three pages written from your own renewal questions will beat thirty written from somebody else's list.

If you cannot tell whether any of it produced anything, that is the first thing to fix. And this is what the work looks like for a professional services firm when it is done properly.

Frequently asked questions

Is our real problem lead generation or something else?

For most brokerages it is the second thing, and I would want the numbers before agreeing to a lead generation campaign. Check two figures first: what proportion of your clients hold only one line with you, and how many of them have been a client for more than three years. If a large share are single-line and long-standing, you are not short of leads, you are absent from a conversation that happens several times a year without you. Recovering one line per client is usually cheaper than acquiring a new client, and it does not require you to compete with a price comparison site. If those two figures are already tight, then yes, acquisition is the right conversation.

What should a brokerage actually publish?

Start with the question you answer on the phone every week. If you spend your mornings explaining business interruption cover to café owners, that is a page, not a phone call. Then the industries you genuinely know: not a page per industry in the phone book sense, but the three or four sectors where you can talk about real risks and real claim patterns. Then the claims page almost nobody writes, which is the single greatest trust asset a broker has and is almost always absent. Everything else is optional. Three good pages beat thirty thin ones, and thirty thin industry pages is the most common mistake I see on brokerage websites.

How do we write about claims without breaking client confidentiality?

Three rules, and you can apply them in ten minutes a week. Aggregate rather than individualise, so you describe a pattern across many claims rather than one client's story. Remove every identifying detail, including location, industry combination, timing and policy size, because the combination of those is often enough to identify a business. And ask before you publish, in writing, even when you think the client would never mind. The strongest content in this space is usually a pattern: what we see most often, why it happens, and what an owner can check this month. That is genuinely useful, it competes with nobody, and it needs no permission.

Does content marketing even work in insurance broking?

It works differently from most industries, and the honest version is that it is slower and narrower. Nobody chooses a broker from a blog post in the way they might choose a café. What content does here is keep you in the consideration set at the moment something changes: a new contract, a claim, a subcontractor, a growth spurt, a bad renewal. That moment is when an owner searches, and if you are not findable for the question they type, the incumbent direct insurer or whoever answers first takes the conversation. So measure it as presence and enquiries rather than as traffic, and give it at least two quarters before judging it.

We are a two-person brokerage. Where should we spend an hour a week?

On the monthly question log and one page. For four weeks, write down every question a client asks you that you answer in more than a minute. At the end of the month, take the most repeated one and write it up properly, with the risk, the common mistake and what an owner should check. Publish it. That is roughly two hours a week and it produces twelve pages a year that are demonstrably about things your clients want to know. The part worth paying someone else for is editing and keeping the publishing rhythm, not the expertise, because the expertise is the thing you already have and it cannot be bought.

How do we know if it is working?

Two numbers, checked quarterly, and neither of them is traffic. First, lines per client, which is the metric that actually moves commission revenue in a brokerage. Second, the share of enquiries that arrive already understanding what you do, which you can only judge by asking at first contact where they found you and what made them call. If lines per client is flat after two quarters of consistent publishing, the content is probably too general and needs to be closer to the questions from your own log. If it is rising, keep going and add the second page rather than the fifth channel.

Before Your Next Renewal Cycle

Two hours before the next cycle starts. Write down the four numbers from section 6. Start the question log today rather than at the beginning of next month. And pick the one page you will finish before your busiest renewal week arrives.

If that page is written and the enquiries it produces are never recorded, the work is invisible by the next quarter. Tell me your lines-per-client figure and I will tell you what I would do first, and if the honest answer is that the brokerage needs to hold what it already has rather than chase new clients, I will say that too.

Are you doing SEO or Ads?

Get a free consultation with us

Stop wasting money on ads that are not working.

Get advertising that is intentional and measured properly.

  • Bring me your current pages, your last quarter of enquiries and your lines-per-client figure, and I will tell you which pages I would write first and what I would stop.
  • You get a short list of pages rather than a campaign proposal, and if the answer is that you should not publish anything yet, I will say so.
free digital marketing consultation

Get in touch with us!

Contact UsContact UsDigital marketing logo light variant
scale your business with sagar sethi

Looking to scale your business?

I offer digital marketing consulting, web design and development services.
Learn MoreDigital marketing logo light variant
Sagar Sethi

About Sagar Sethi

I came to Australia in 2006 with $500 to my name and a dream to make it big. No job was big or small as long as I stuck to my values and it got closer to my goals. Today I run a successful digital marketing agency. 


It has always operated with a 'Human First' approach. Our values keep us square and keep the fluff out. We have worked with some of the biggest names in Australian business. 

Latest Blog

View All Blogs

Awards & Certifications

Xugar's curved branding element, representing innovative marketing consulting

WINNER

Web Excellence
Awards
2024
Xugar's curved branding element, representing innovative marketing consulting

FINALIST

Australian Small Business Champion Awards
2024
Xugar's curved branding element, representing innovative marketing consulting

FINALIST

Business xCellence Awards
2024
Xugar's curved branding element, representing innovative marketing consulting

WINNER

Local Business
Awards
2024

Book a free 30-minute Strategy Session

Tell me a bit about your business and we can dial in a strategy that fits.

    sagar sethi
    linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram

    Xugar Holiday Offer